You know it’s an important decision. You also know there are many firms to choose from. Ultimately, when you hire a consulting firm, you ask people to be an extension of your organization. You’ll be working closely together, so you need someone who is easy to collaborate with, adaptable, and understands your industry’s nuances — they'll serve you better because of it. With that in mind, what should you consider when choosing the right consulting partner?
Related Content: 4 Steps to Strengthen Your Consultant Partnership
To help you find the perfect partner, we’ve put together several important factors to keep in mind when selecting a consultant firm, such as their expertise and services, how well they communicate and collaborate, and possible financial and legal considerations.
# 4 Key Areas To Consider When Hiring a Consulting Partner
1. Expertise and Services
2. Culture, Communication, and Collaboration
3. Delivery Approach
4. Financial and Legal Considerations
# 1. Expertise and Services
You want a partner that will help you succeed, so they should have a history of being a high performer with a record of success. It’s important to look at their experience, the services they offer, and their reputation.
- Industry Expertise and Experience: Ideally, you want to hire a business consultant firm with a strong track record of success in your industry. Look at their project experiences, case studies, client testimonials, and project outcomes to ensure they have the expertise you require for success. Consultants with real-world, hands-on experience will understand your industry’s challenges and opportunities and will be able to deliver effective industry-tailored solutions.
- Specialization and Services Offered: Be sure the firm offers services that align with your needs or the specific area you need help with. Firms may specialize in certain areas such as change management, strategy, technology, or operations. Also, assess whether you need support with setting a strategy or an implementation partner to execute your vision. Some firms are willing to go beyond building the strategy and dive in to help you execute it with end-to-end delivery.
- Reputation: Take time to research the firm’s reputation in the industry. Online reviews, recommendations from colleagues, awards and recognition, and references from past clients can provide valuable insights into their professionalism and quality of work.
# 2. Culture, Communication, and Collaboration
When hiring a consulting firm, you’re hiring someone that will help guide you to success. This requires consultants to gain alignment across your organization, effectively communicate a vision for change, and collaborate to execute. Paying attention to a consultant firm’s culture and communication style will give you a good indication of how they will collaborate with you on a project.
- Cultural Fit: Your organization’s culture is the set of values, norms, and behaviors rooted in all that you do. As consultants integrate into your organization and work in tandem with teams, having a strong cultural fit can lead to smoother collaboration and better results. For example, is your organization an advocate of diversity and inclusion? You’ll likely want to find a firm with a similar ethos. Take steps to discover whether the firm's values and working style align with your organization's culture by asking questions about their own workplace culture, values, and mission statements during your introductory calls and meetings. Curious to learn more about Propeller’s ethos? Read more here.
- Communication Skills: Alongside fitting in with your company’s culture comes effective communication, which is critical for a successful consulting engagement. Establish that the consultants are good listeners and communicators. You want them to hear and understand your needs and also clearly convey their ideas and recommendations. Pay close attention to how the consultant team interacts while interviewing. They should be paying attention to your needs and demonstrating the ability to give an honest, unbiased opinion about any challenges and how to resolve them — and not offering up a cookie-cutter solution.
- Client Involvement: Since collaboration and knowledge transfer are important for the long-term success of your project, a good consultant should involve you and your team in the process, see you as a partner, and be willing to build capabilities within your organization to create a long-lasting impact. Reviewing customer testimonials and asking for references is a good way to get a comprehensive understanding of how your consultant will involve your team.
Did you know? We’re proudly certified as a women-owned business by the Women’s Business Enterprise National Council (WBENC), a leading certifier of businesses owned and operated by women.
# 3. Delivery Approach
Each organization and project is unique. During your research phase and early conversations, look for a firm that shows that it understands the importance of a customized delivery approach along with an innovative, problem-solving mindset.
- Customization: Each project is different, so a good consultant firm should be able to tailor their approach to your specific needs rather than applying a one-size-fits-all solution. Here are a few ways you can find out if the firm uses a customized approach:
- During your initial discussions, has the management consulting firm taken the time to research you as well? They should have done their own investigation to understand your organization, goals, and challenges that factor into the project.
- Do their recommended strategies and plans align with your mission, vision, and brand?
- Are they willing to provide ongoing support and training if needed?
- Problem-Solving Ability: Problem-solving helps discover issues or processes that need to change and develop solutions to achieve the necessary changes. That means business consultants should have a strong analytical and problem-solving mindset. Paying attention to their ability to identify issues and provide innovative solutions is a key aspect of their value and the success of your project.
- Innovative Thinking: Along with being problem solvers, the firm should be innovative and creative in their solutions. The consulting firm should bring fresh insights and original ideas to the table. Their ability to think creatively and challenge the status quo can provide significant value. However, to be a truly innovative consultant, ideas should be informed by a mixture of creativity and data. The firm should use data-driven approaches and share concrete insights and analytics that explain how they plan to solve your issues. Look at their case studies, white papers, and blogs to learn more about how they used innovative thinking to successfully solve problems for previous clients.
# 4. Financial and Legal Considerations
Hiring a business consulting firm is an investment in time and money, so it’s important to consider the costs and scope associated with the project and any legalities depending on the type of business. These are things that you should discover during your initial conversations. If they don’t meet your needs and expectations, they may not be the right consultant for your project.
- Budget and Costs: Understand the firm's pricing structure and confirm that it aligns with your budget. Look for a firm that is fair and transparent about its pricing structure for the business consultant services offered. Does their cost match with the services they will be providing? If they don’t explain how they reach the pricing structure upfront, ask them to explain. Be sure to keep in mind how your requirements impact costs. For example, do you need senior-level strategy support or perhaps a partner that can integrate into your team and collaborate with C-Suite stakeholders? Your budget should reflect those needs.
- Timeline: Discuss the expected timeline for the project and make sure it meets your business needs. Define the scope and necessary due dates to clearly communicate your expectations to help keep projects on track and within budget. Consultants should be able to set realistic expectations for deliverables and milestones and help avoid scope creep.
- Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA): If your project involves sensitive information, you’ll want to guarantee that the consultant firm will sign an NDA to protect your intellectual property and confidential data. Additionally, you might consider having the potential consultant agencies sign an NDA upfront. This allows you to discuss your project needs more openly without the concern of intellectual property loss should you choose to go with a different firm.
# Propeller’s Expert Business Consultants Are Here to Help
Remember that choosing a consultant firm is not just about picking the biggest name or the cheapest option — it’s about finding a partner who can genuinely understand your needs, add value, and help you achieve your goals.
At Propeller, our people make us who we are and allow us to make momentum for you. We are a team of experienced problem-solvers — consultants, strategists, builders, and doers — here to provide customized, innovative solutions and tools derived from data-driven results that help businesses thrive in change. We believe in a people-focused partnership approach that has continued to deliver successful solutions for our clients.
We love complex challenges. If you’re ready to tackle the next big thing together, let’s talk.
